Can an Heir Sell a Deceased Estate Property Before an Executor Is Appointed?
Short answer: No. In Pakade and Others v Pato and Others [2026] ZAWCHC 710 (delivered on 18 November 2026), the Western Cape High Court confirmed that a deed of sale signed by an heir without formal authority from the Master of the High Court is void ab initio (invalid from the start). Even a unanimous family resolution and urgent funeral expenses cannot make the sale lawful - and an executor appointed later cannot retroactively ratify it.
Case Summary: Pakade v Pato [2026] ZAWCHC 710
| Case Name | Pakade and Others v Pato and Others (Case Nos. 2025/053582; 2026/044686) |
|---|---|
| Citation | [2026] ZAWCHC 710 |
| Court & Judge | High Court of South Africa, Western Cape Division, Cape Town - Bingwa AJ |
| Date Delivered | 18 November 2026 |
| Key Statutes | Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965 (ss 13(1), 18(3), 47); Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981 (s 2(1)); Constitution, 1996 (s 173) |
| Outcome | Deed of sale declared void ab initio; applicants ordered to pay costs of both the application and counter-claim, including counsel. |
What Happened
The late Zolile Xhonyeka Mazwayi died intestate on 22 September 2022. The sole asset in the estate was a 225 square metre residential property in Mfuleni, Cape Town.
Struggling to pay for the funeral, the family met on 27 September 2022 and agreed to sell the house. Three days later, on 30 September 2022, one of the heirs (Lulama Tracy Pakade) signed a written deed of sale purporting to sell the property to Mzwanele and Nolizwi Tsholoba for R150,000. At that stage, nobody had been issued Letters of Executorship or Letters of Authority by the Master.
The purchasers paid the full purchase price in two parts:
- R50,000 paid directly towards funeral arrangements; and
- R100,000 deposited into the applicants' attorneys' trust account.
Two years later, on 22 September 2024, another intestate heir (Luyanda Pato) obtained formal appointment from the Master to administer the estate. He refused to recognise the 2022 sale or sign transfer documents. The heir who had signed the sale and the two purchasers approached the Western Cape High Court to compel transfer - or, alternatively, to force the executor to ratify the sale - arguing that the buyers had acted in good faith to assist a bereaved family and that the executor was withholding transfer to collect rental income.
Why the Court Declared the Sale Void
1. An heir has no legal capacity to sell estate property
Under section 13(1) of the Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965, no person may liquidate or distribute a deceased estate unless formally authorised by the Master. Upon death, control of the estate vests in the Master until appointment is granted. A family resolution, no matter how urgent the financial need, gives an heir zero locus standi to sell immovable property belonging to the estate.
2. Statutory formalities under the Alienation of Land Act were breached
Section 2(1) of the Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981 requires any sale of immovable property to be in writing and signed by the parties or by agents acting under written authority. Because the signing heir was neither the registered owner nor an authorised executor or agent, the contract contravened both Acts and was a legal nullity from day one.
3. A void sale cannot be ratified later under section 47
The applicants argued that section 47 of the Administration of Estates Act allows a property to be sold even where heirs disagree. Acting Judge Bingwa rejected this, pointing out that section 47 applies only to an already appointed executor. Following Mar-Deon Broedery CC v Marais NO and Others [2021] ZAGPPHC 887, any approval by the Master of the manner and conditions of sale must take place before the agreement is concluded - not ex post facto. Because the 2022 agreement was void ab initio, it could not be rescued by later ratification.
4. Section 173 of the Constitution will not override estate statutes
The applicants urged the Court to use its inherent power under section 173 of the Constitution to develop the common law and protect bona fide purchasers. Relying on King NO v De Jager [2021] ZACC 4, Mukaddam v Pioneer Foods 2013 (5) SA 89 (CC), and Bester NO v Master of the High Court [2023] ZAWCHC, the Court refused. Judicial powers cannot be used to bypass explicit statutory safeguards enacted to prevent fraud and ensure the orderly winding-up of deceased estates.
What Happens to the Buyers' Money?
Although the buyers lost any claim to the house - and were hit with an adverse costs order - the judgment highlighted two important points about recovering their funds:
- Money held in trust is recoverable: The R100,000 paid into the attorneys' trust account remained safeguarded and easily recoverable.
- Direct cash payments require a separate claim: For the R50,000 paid directly towards funeral expenses, the buyers acquired no right to the property. Citing Moletsane v Occupiers of Erf 9[...], Tsakane, Brakpan and Another [2026] ZAGPJHC 1137, the Court noted that buyers who pay an unauthorised seller must pursue a separate contractual restitution or unjustified enrichment claim against that individual.
Practical Lessons for Buyers and Heirs
- Verify authority before signing: Never sign an Offer to Purchase for a deceased estate property without seeing the seller's original Letters of Executorship or section 18(3) Letters of Authority issued by the Master. See our property purchaser checklist before committing to a sale.
- Never pay deposits directly to family members: Always pay deposits exclusively into the transferring conveyancer's trust account. Had the buyers in Pakade paid the full R150,000 directly to the family, recovering it would have been far harder.
- Do not bypass the Master for urgent expenses: For small estates valued under R250,000, family members can apply relatively quickly for a section 18(3) Letter of Authority at the Master's Office or designated Magistrate's Court rather than attempting an informal sale. Learn more in our guide to deceased estate administration.
- Use the proper remedy for a rogue executor: If heirs believe a duly appointed executor is failing in their fiduciary duties or improperly collecting rental income, the correct step is to apply to the Master for the executor's removal - not to enforce an unlawful pre-appointment sale.
Buying or selling property out of a deceased estate? Have a conveyancer review the Master's Letters of Executorship or Authority and draft the deed of sale before any money changes hands. You can also estimate your deceased estate property transfer costs upfront.